Whence Social Justice, Homelessness and Atheism?Atheism is intrinsic to my commitment to social justice because a) it tells us that there is no God or afterlife, meaning b) that the here and now is all that exists, and has ever existed, and we have to make the most of it; and c) it renders it ethically unacceptable that anybody’s short…Atheism is intrinsic to my commitment to social justice because a) it tells us that there is no God or afterlife, meaning b) that the here and now is all that exists, and has ever existed, and we have to make the most of it; and c) it renders it ethically unacceptable that anybody’s short time on this planet be spent in misery, especially d) given the human (rather than divine) nature of the agency that shapes the social and economic structures that generate these unjust outcomes. Hence, the moral urgency of ‘ending homelessness’ is, for me, not rooted in religious belief but rather in the rejection of such belief...

But the key points here are that a) it can feel unacceptable to explicitly articulate an atheist position at homelessness conferences and similar contexts where it is expected that other belief systems will be politely entertained, and b) embedded in the elision of faith and values noted above, there sometimes appears an assumption that atheism is ‘value-less’ in both senses of the word (i.e., it excludes the holder from possessing a moral core – “If God is dead, everything is permitted” (Mackie, 1977, p.227) – and it has no worth).

Some of this sense of being silenced may be down to self-censorship on the part of atheists; I have yet to hear an atheist speak up for their own value system or challenge the veracity or impact of faith-based world views at relevant events. So I guess we can’t be sure what the reaction would be were we to do so. But I would suggest that our collective silence is borne from painful experience of the extraordinarily strong reactions that tend to be provoked when people’s faith is questioned by non-believers. These reactions are usually justified on the basis that one must
‘respect’ other people’s belief systems, but it is seldom made clear what ‘respect’ demands in this context.

The most basic (and surely uncontroversial?) point for me is one of parity of treatment. In contexts where atheists are expected to listen respectfully to accounts of religious values and inspiration, there should be an expectation that people of faith listen to those of us without faith, about our non faith, with equal respect. People of faith should be no more entitled to take ‘offence’ at the world view of atheists – i.e., our rejection of their metaphysics – than we atheists are expected to take offence at the implicit dismissal of our world view in religious belief. Equity requires, of course, that the reverse position also holds; in contexts where atheist views are being aired freely.

Time, then, for atheists to speak up routinely for their values at homelessness conferences and other gatherings, and demand the same respect and ‘tolerance’ as is given to other world views? Perhaps. On the other hand, one could argue that ‘peaceful co-existence’ might be better served by a simple acceptance that the values and metaphysics that drive our commitment to shared goals, such as ending homelessness, are many and varied and not necessarily religiously-inspired, and as such may often be better left unsaid in ‘mixed’ company.

Suzanne Fitzpatrick
Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, UKJoe
https://bit.ly/3HlritN

Comments

Popular posts from this blog